Age is the first thing we look at. A tank water heater in the Fort Wayne area typically lasts 8 to 12 years, and the hard water here will tend to push a lot of them toward the lower end of that range. Repair is definitely warranted on a heater that's not quite at the end of its life. A bad thermocouple, a faulty gas control valve, a burnt-out element, or a stuck thermostat can all be rectified in a single visit as long as the tank itself is in good shape.
Some problems can't be repaired, though. Rusty hot water usually means the anode rod is spent and the tank lining is going. Loud popping or rumbling is sediment that's baked onto the bottom, and by the time it's doing that, it's been overheating for a while. Water pooling at the base, coming out of the tank itself, means the tank has split. No part of it can be fixed.
Here's the pattern we see most frequently. The heater starts to get noisy, the hot water runs out much quicker, and the recovery time is a lot longer. Homeowners will just live with it for a few months. Then the tank finally lets go, and a scheduled replacement becomes an emergency one, complete with wet carpet, drywall cuts, and a heap of ruined storage boxes in the basement. If you're due to replace it on your own schedule, it will almost always be cheaper. If it's 10 years old and you're seeing any of those symptoms, then call before it picks the date for you.